| | | | | | |

Core i3-4170 vs i5-8500


Description
The i3-4170 is based on Haswell architecture while the i5-8500 is based on Coffee Lake.

Using the multithread performance as a reference, the i3-4170 gets a score of 92.7 k points while the i5-8500 gets 307.5 k points.

Summarizing, the i5-8500 is 3.3 times faster than the i3-4170. To get a proper comparison between both models, take a look to the data shown below.

Specs
CPUID
306c3
906ea
Core
Haswell
Coffee Lake-S
Architecture
Base frecuency
3.7 GHz
3 GHz
Boost frecuency
3.7 GHz
4.1 GHz
Socket
LGA1150
LGA 1151
Cores/Threads
2/4
6/6
TDP
54 W
65 W
Cache L1 (d+i)
2x32+2x32 kB
6x32+6x32 kB
Cache L2
2x256 kB
6x256 kB
Cache L3
3072 kB
9216 kB
Date
March 2015
March 2018
Mean monothread perf.
44.24k points
69.09k points
Mean multithread perf.
92.71k points
307.52k points

Non-optimized benchmark
The benchmark in Mode 0 (FPU) measures cpu performance with non-optimized software. It uses the basic µinstructions from the i386 architecture with the i387 floating point unit. This mode is compatible with all CPUs so it's practical to compare very different CPUs
Monothread
i3-4170
i5-8500
Test#1 (Integers)
4.24k
4.19k (x0.99)
Test#2 (FP)
10.58k
17.38k (x1.64)
Test#3 (Generic, ZIP)
4.87k
5.46k (x1.12)
Test#1 (Memory)
4.2k
11.92k (x2.84)
TOTAL
23.88k
38.96k (x1.63)

Multithread

i3-4170

i5-8500
Test#1 (Integers)
7.7k
27.67k (x3.59)
Test#2 (FP)
27.14k
94.07k (x3.47)
Test#3 (Generic, ZIP)
11.48k
29.05k (x2.53)
Test#1 (Memory)
2.68k
4.39k (x1.64)
TOTAL
49k
155.18k (x3.17)

SSE3 optimized benchmark
The benchmark in mode I (SSE) is optimized for the use of SIMD instructions with 128 bits register and the SSE set up to version 3. Nearly every modern CPU has support for this mode.
Monothread
i3-4170
i5-8500
Test#1 (Integers)
13.1k
15.22k (x1.16)
Test#2 (FP)
11.68k
22.02k (x1.89)
Test#3 (Generic, ZIP)
5.07k
5.75k (x1.13)
Test#1 (Memory)
4.19k
12.17k (x2.91)
TOTAL
34.04k
55.17k (x1.62)

Multithread

i3-4170

i5-8500
Test#1 (Integers)
25.81k
87.78k (x3.4)
Test#2 (FP)
25k
126.73k (x5.07)
Test#3 (Generic, ZIP)
11.96k
32.93k (x2.75)
Test#1 (Memory)
3.87k
4.22k (x1.09)
TOTAL
66.65k
251.65k (x3.78)

AVX optimized benchmark
The benchmark in mode II (AVX) is optimized to used 256 bits registers beside the first version of the Advanced Vector Extensions (AVX). The first AVX compatible CPU was released in 2011.
Monothread
i3-4170
i5-8500
Test#1 (Integers)
13.24k
15.21k (x1.15)
Test#2 (FP)
12.37k
22.94k (x1.85)
Test#3 (Generic, ZIP)
5.11k
5.54k (x1.08)
Test#1 (Memory)
4.17k
11.39k (x2.73)
TOTAL
34.89k
55.07k (x1.58)

Multithread

i3-4170

i5-8500
Test#1 (Integers)
28.15k
79.52k (x2.82)
Test#2 (FP)
29.95k
107.78k (x3.6)
Test#3 (Generic, ZIP)
11.84k
31.89k (x2.69)
Test#1 (Memory)
2.73k
13.37k (x4.89)
TOTAL
72.68k
232.55k (x3.2)

AVX2 optimized benchmark
The benchmark in mode III (AVX2), like AVX1, is optimized to used 256 bits registers beside the second version of the Advanced Vector Extensions (AVX). The first AVX2 compatible CPU was released in 2013.
Monothread
i3-4170
i5-8500
Test#1 (Integers)
22.17k
27.36k (x1.23)
Test#2 (FP)
12.58k
24.27k (x1.93)
Test#3 (Generic, ZIP)
5.09k
5.69k (x1.12)
Test#1 (Memory)
4.4k
11.77k (x2.67)
TOTAL
44.24k
69.09k (x1.56)

Multithread

i3-4170

i5-8500
Test#1 (Integers)
47k
144.77k (x3.08)
Test#2 (FP)
31.06k
129.04k (x4.15)
Test#3 (Generic, ZIP)
11.96k
29.53k (x2.47)
Test#1 (Memory)
2.68k
4.18k (x1.56)
TOTAL
92.71k
307.52k (x3.32)

Performance/W
i3-4170
i5-8500
Test#1 (Integers)
870 points/W
2227 points/W
Test#2 (FP)
575 points/W
1985 points/W
Test#3 (Generic, ZIP)
222 points/W
454 points/W
Test#1 (Memory)
50 points/W
64 points/W
TOTAL
1717 points/W
4731 points/W

Performance/GHz
i3-4170
i5-8500
Test#1 (Integers)
5991 points/GHz
6673 points/GHz
Test#2 (FP)
3401 points/GHz
5920 points/GHz
Test#3 (Generic, ZIP)
1375 points/GHz
1388 points/GHz
Test#1 (Memory)
1189 points/GHz
2870 points/GHz
TOTAL
11956 points/GHz
16850 points/GHz

Monothread performance graph
Monothread performance graphics gives the performance vs time. They are useful to measure the time it takes to the CPU to reach the maximum performance.

Usually, CPU's performance will be steady during these tests but if it has a slow frequency strategy, the first samples will show a lower score.


Test#1 (Integers) [points vs time]

grafica bm.hardlimit.com


Test#2 (FP) [points vs time]

grafica bm.hardlimit.com


Test#3 (Generic, ZIP) [points vs time]

grafica bm.hardlimit.com


Test#1 (Memory) [points vs time]

grafica bm.hardlimit.com

Multithread performance graph
Multithread graphs measure the performance against a heavy load during certain time.

If CPU's TDP doesn't limit the frequency and the machine is properly cooled, performance should remain steady vs time. Otherwise, the performance score will oscillate or decrease over time.


Test#1 (Integers) [points vs time]

grafica bm.hardlimit.com


Test#2 (FP) [points vs time]

grafica bm.hardlimit.com


Test#3 (Generic, ZIP) [points vs time]

grafica bm.hardlimit.com


Test#1 (Memory) [points vs time]

grafica bm.hardlimit.com

Hardlimit Benchmark Central - Ver. 3.11.4